Here it is cleaned up and easy to follow:
🧙♂️ Butterbeer (Frozen / Creamy Style)
Ingredients
2 cups vanilla ice cream
2 cups cream soda (frozen into ice cubes)
1 cup cream soda (liquid)
2 tsp butter extract (or imitation butter flavoring)
1 tsp rum extract (non-alcoholic)
4 tbsp butterscotch topping
Pinch of salt
Whipped cream (for topping)
Instructions
Prep ahead
Pour cream soda into an ice cube tray and freeze until solid.
Blend
In a blender, combine:
Vanilla ice cream
Cream soda ice cubes
Liquid cream soda
Butter extract
Rum extract
Butterscotch topping
Pinch of salt
Blend until smooth and thick.
Serve
Pour into a frosty mug.
Top it off
Add a generous swirl of whipped cream.
Drizzle extra butterscotch topping over the top.
Tips (this is where you can tweak it to your taste)
Want it richer? Add a splash of heavy cream.
Want it less sweet? Cut the butterscotch down to 2–3 tbsp.
The adult version...
Now we’re talking 😄 — turning this into an adult Butterbeer is a very good idea.
Here’s a version that keeps that creamy, butterscotch “theme park” vibe but adds a smooth kick without overpowering it.
🧙♂️ Boozy Butterbeer (Frozen Adult Version)
Ingredients
2 cups vanilla ice cream
2 cups cream soda ice cubes
¾ cup cream soda (liquid)
2 tsp butter extract
3–4 tbsp butterscotch topping
Pinch of salt
Alcohol (choose your style)
2 oz vanilla vodka (clean + sweet)
or
2 oz spiced rum (warm, deeper flavor)
or (best combo)
1 oz vanilla vodka + 1 oz spiced rum
Topping
Whipped cream
Extra butterscotch drizzle
Instructions
Freeze your cream soda into ice cubes ahead of time.
Add everything (except toppings) to a blender.
Blend until thick, smooth, and frosty.
Pour into a chilled mug.
Top with whipped cream and a heavy drizzle of butterscotch.
🔥 Pro Tips (this is where it gets really good)
Best alcohol combo: Vanilla vodka + spiced rum gives that “buttery caramel + warmth” flavor that’s closest to the real thing.
Stronger drink: Add an extra ½ oz alcohol, but don’t go too far or it’ll thin out the texture.
Thicker texture: Add more ice cream or a few regular ice cubes.
Salt matters: That tiny pinch boosts the butterscotch like crazy — don’t skip it.
🥶 Want it Pub-Style Instead? (Non-frozen)
Skip the blender:
Mix 1 cup cold cream soda + 1½ oz alcohol
Stir in 1 tbsp butterscotch
Top with whipped cream